ML Coaching
You want to lose fat, look more defined and get your body in shape. So you go into a calorie deficit. For a while it works. The scale shows less, the clothes fit more loosely. But at some point nothing happens anymore. Your energy level drops, your motivation too. What happened? Quite simply: you were in a deficit for too long. In this article I'll show you why a permanent calorie deficit is counterproductive, what the science says about it and how to do it better.
What happens during a calorie deficit?
A calorie deficit means you feed your body less energy than it burns. To balance the difference, it draws on stored energy, ideally from fat deposits. This works very well in the first weeks. But our body is adaptable. When it notices that too little energy is coming in permanently, it slows down the metabolism, saves energy and reduces hormonal processes.
What studies say about a permanent calorie deficit
Scientific investigations show that a permanent calorie deficit can not only lower the basal metabolic rate, but also has negative effects on the hormone balance. In a study by Keys et al. (1950), known as the "Minnesota Starvation Study", it emerged: after just a few weeks in a strong deficit, there was increased irritability, muscle wasting, loss of libido and depressive moods.
More recent investigations also confirm: a deficit that lasts too long can lead to an underactive thyroid, listlessness and a decline in fat-free mass, even with simultaneous training.
Typical symptoms of a deficit that lasts too long
If you notice these signs, your calorie deficit has become a burden over time:
- Stagnation in weight or muscle loss despite training
- Sleep problems and chronic fatigue
- Irritability and mental exhaustion
- Cravings and mood swings
- Menstrual irregularities (in women)
Example from practice: Sarah's path to balance
Sarah, 34, was highly motivated and wanted to reduce her body fat percentage in 12 weeks. She lowered her calories significantly, trained 5x a week and avoided "unhealthy" foods. The first results were there. But after 6 weeks everything stagnated. She was tired, had no strength left in training and kept having binges on the weekend.
With these problems she finally came to me. Her mindset was already set on the idea that a defined body simply isn't for her and that she has to accept that. A typical negative mood, as you experience it with a permanent calorie deficit.
All the easier was the solution to the problem: together we developed a plan for the following weeks. We reduced the deficit, improved the nutrient density and scheduled a refeed phase. The result: more energy, renewed desire for training and a constant fat loss, entirely without pressure. Sarah was finally able to reach her goal. Admittedly only after 14 weeks, but at least not completely starved and with more energy.
Why the metabolism adapts
The body isn't stupid. When too little energy comes in permanently, it goes into energy-saving mode. That means:
- Reduced basal metabolic rate (you burn less at rest)
- Less spontaneous activity (you move less unconsciously)
- Changed hormone production (leptin drops, ghrelin rises)
- Increased cortisol levels (stress hormone)
A permanent calorie deficit can therefore achieve exactly the opposite: instead of continuing to lose fat, your body holds on to its reserves.
How to do it better: strategies for long-term success
Instead of pushing through for months, your body needs phases. You can picture this like a training cycle. Here are four strategies that work:
- Limit deficit phases: a maximum of 8 to 12 weeks, then switch to maintenance calories or a slight building phase
- Refeed days: 1 to 2 days per week with more calories, especially from carbohydrates
- Reverse dieting: a gradual increase in calories after the diet to stabilise the metabolism
- Training adjustment: in deficit phases, focus on technique and maintenance instead of maximal strength
What to watch out for when getting back in
If you've been in a deficit for a long time, you shouldn't suddenly ramp up drastically. Observe your body, increase your calories slowly (100 to 150 kcal per week), pay attention to your biofeedback signals: sleep, hunger, performance, mood.
During this phase, a focus on muscle building can also be worthwhile. Because more muscle mass increases your basal metabolic rate and helps you be able to eat more in the future without gaining fat.
Conclusion: a permanent calorie deficit? Better not.
A calorie deficit is a tool, not a permanent state. If you eat too little permanently, you'll stagnate sooner or later. You feel worse, lose muscle and block your own success long term. The better strategy: plan phases, consciously allow maintenance, supply your body with energy and then deliberately go into the next round.
I'm Marco Laterza, personal trainer in Zurich. If you want to know how to lose fat without falling into the permanent-diet trap, then get in touch with me. Together we'll develop a strategy that fits your everyday life, your goal and your body. Sustainable, effective and without extremism.